Posted on

Is a Million Dollar Higher Education Really Worth It?

Press Play to Hear This Post

Insights from The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast Episode #28

Higher education remains one of the most significant financial commitments a family can make. For many high-performance professionals, saving for their children’s college education is a crucial part of their financial planning strategy. But in 2020, with the price tag for four years of private college often nearing or exceeding $250,000—and graduate programs adding even more to the bill—it’s natural to ask: Is a million-dollar education really worth it?

In this article, I’m bringing insights from a recent in-depth discussion I had on the Mind Money Spectrum Podcast that explores the true value of college. As a fee-only fiduciary advisor, my focus is on delivering clear, actionable guidance you can use to make smart financial decisions—not just chasing the traditional checklist.

Understanding the Link Between Education and Income

It’s a well-documented fact that, on average, households with college-educated members tend to earn higher incomes. This correlation has led many families to view college education as an investment in future earning potential. But the reality is much more nuanced. Often, the types of individuals who pursue higher education already possess traits such as motivation, discipline, and certain social skills that contribute significantly to their success.

A striking finding from research on elite universities showed that applicants who were qualified for, but chose not to attend, top schools tend to have similar long-term outcomes as those who did attend. This suggests that the value may lie more in the qualities of the student than the piece of paper itself.

The Opportunity Cost: Experience vs. Education

Another way to frame the question is to consider what your child might gain by entering the workforce immediately instead of attending college. Ten years’ worth of work experience can sometimes provide practical skills, networks, and income that rival what could be earned post-degree. Particularly in fields like software engineering or skilled trades, where proficiency matters more than formal credentials, this path could be financially and personally rewarding.

From my own perspective, I found that much of my most applicable learning came from hands-on work experience rather than academic study. Real-world problem-solving fosters critical thinking and adaptability in ways that traditional classroom settings sometimes fail to deliver. That said, this pathway requires maturity and self-motivation—qualities not every teenager may have at 18.

The Intangible Value of College

College offers more than textbook knowledge. It can be a powerful environment to cultivate self-discipline, learn how to learn independently, and build lasting professional and social networks. These hidden assets often translate into opportunities down the road.

Networking effects, for example, might open doors to jobs or mentorships that could otherwise be difficult to access. Moreover, the structure of higher education encourages the development of critical thinking and communication skills that are valuable in almost any career.

Considering the Financial Reality

Now let’s talk dollars and cents. Imagine you’ve saved $1 million earmarked for your child’s higher education. Instead of paying tuition, what if you invested that money in a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds—the very assets I favor—and gave your child the option of withdrawing 3% annually? That would provide about $30,000 a year for life, adjusting for inflation, without depleting the principal. For many young people, this guaranteed lifelong income stream might offer greater financial freedom than the traditional college route.

How would your child weigh having lifelong financial independence versus going into debt or spending large sums upfront for a degree? The reality is most teenagers, when given these choices hypothetically, might choose the ongoing income over costly tuition, especially if they believe they can learn valuable skills outside of academia.

Changing Landscape of Education Access and Alternatives

Twenty years ago, alternatives to traditional education were limited. Today, elite institutions openly offer many courses online for free, making high-quality knowledge more accessible than ever before. If your child is motivated, they could obtain similar educational value at a fraction of the cost.

Furthermore, trades and skilled professions continue to provide lucrative, stable career paths without the burden of expensive degrees. Apprenticeships and certifications in plumbing, electrician work, elevator maintenance, or technology fields might be viable options that deserve equal consideration in your financial plans.

Addressing Income Inequality and the Educational Divide

An essential part of this conversation is understanding why some families save so aggressively for college while others struggle just to cover living expenses. Income inequality plays a significant role; wealthier households often emphasize college education from early childhood, building an environment that encourages academic success and college attendance almost as a given.

By contrast, families with limited resources face immediate concerns: paying bills, affording food, and managing survival day to day. In these circumstances, planning for higher education can seem abstract and unattainable. This context is critical when designing financial strategies and setting realistic expectations for your children’s futures.

Practical Financial Planning Considerations

Given these complexities, what can you do as a high-income professional planning for your family’s financial security and freedom?

  • Set clear, flexible objectives: Saving for college is commendable, but avoid rigidly earmarking funds without considering alternatives. Keep funds liquid or in tax-advantaged accounts like 529 plans that allow flexibility if priorities shift.
  • Consider a lifelong financial support framework: Instead of front-loading all investments into college tuition, create an approach that allows your child ongoing financial support. This can empower them to choose education, entrepreneurship, or apprenticeships based on their evolving interests.
  • Focus on teaching self-improvement and financial literacy: Encourage your children to value continuous learning, whether in formal settings or through self-directed study. Provide financial education early on so they understand the trade-offs and opportunity costs involved in their decisions.
  • Invest in a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds: As a fee-only fiduciary, I recommend building long-term wealth through well-constructed stock and bond portfolios, avoiding alternatives that tend to have higher fees and less transparency.
  • Evaluate the practical impact of college choice: Not all institutions deliver equal returns. Research schools for their career outcomes, costs, and networking benefits rather than assuming the most prestigious or expensive option is always best.
  • Discuss career options beyond college: Bring tradespeople and professionals with diverse backgrounds into conversations to broaden your child’s perspective on alternative pathways.

Conclusion: The True Value of Education Is Personal

Ultimately, there is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether a million-dollar higher education is “worth it.” It depends greatly on your child’s maturity, goals, learning style, and the evolving economic environment. As financial stewards, our job is to provide guidance and resources that enable informed decisions without forcing preconceived notions.

I encourage families to frame the question more broadly: What combination of financial resources, education options, and lifelong learning will best prepare my child for a fulfilling and financially secure future? That mindset sets you on the path to true financial freedom—not just the freedom to pay college bills.

If you’re interested in exploring personalized strategies for balancing college savings, investment management, and long-term wealth accumulation, please reach out for a consultation. As a fee-only fiduciary advisor, I prioritize your family’s goals and offer transparent, actionable advice without conflicts of interest.

Remember, the best investment you can make is in knowledge—whether inside or outside the classroom.

Press Play to Dive Deeper with The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast

Need More Help?

If you’re ever in need of guidance, these blog posts may be of help. But be sure to contact a financial, tax, or legal professional for guidance and information specific to your individual situation. And as always you can reach out to me directly here with questions or concerns about your personal situation.

Stay Updated with Investing Forever Advisory

* indicates required


Disclaimer

  • The information provided in the blog post is for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be considered as financial advice or a recommendation to invest in any specific investment or investment strategy.
  • Past performance is not indicative of future results, and any investment involves risks, including the potential loss of principal.
  • The financial advisor makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, and shall not be liable for any damages arising from any reliance on or use of such information.
  • Any views or opinions expressed in the blog post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the financial advisor’s firm or its affiliates.
  • The financial advisor’s firm may have positions in some of the securities or investments discussed in the blog post, and such positions may change at any time without notice.
  • Investors should consult with a financial advisor or professional to determine their own investment objectives, risk tolerance, and other factors before making any investment decisions.
  • This post has been edited for completeness and includes material generated with the assistance of ChatGPT.
    • Posted on

    Should Your Daughter Go to Cornell or NotCornell?

    Press Play to Hear This Post

    Insights from The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast Episode #156

    College decisions can feel monumental—especially when your child has full rides to multiple universities, ranging from prestigious Ivy League schools like Cornell to solid public universities that might feel more “NotCornell.” As a fiduciary financial advisor working with high-performance professionals, I often get the question: Should your child invest four years at a traditional university, or is there a better path? This question goes beyond emotional ties and brand prestige. It digs into the core of financial security and freedom, aiming to maximize return on both investment and personal development.

    In episode #156 of the Mind Money Spectrum podcast (published Tue, 09 Dec 2025), the topic of choosing between Cornell and what I’ve dubbed “NotCornell” was dissected to separate the tangible from the intangible value colleges provide. What struck me most is how much the conversation emphasizes that the real cost of college isn’t always the tuition; it’s often the opportunity cost of time, the quality and practicality of the education, and the life experience — which all must be balanced against the evolving landscape of education today.

    Why the Traditional College Narrative Needs an Update

    There was a time when higher education was the primary elevator to financial success. Graduates of elite schools clustered in good jobs, creating a feedback loop of prestige and opportunity. But consider these facts:

    • Many courses at top universities are now freely available online.
    • The cost of tuition, room, and board has increased much faster than inflation for decades.
    • The rise of AI and technology means practical skills and adaptability often trump foundational theoretical knowledge.
    • Jobs increasingly emphasize real-world experience and specific skills over brand-name degrees.

    Consequently, the value proposition of paying for an expensive education needs scrutiny. Is paying for a Cornell experience truly more valuable than going to a quality state school or even pursuing a non-traditional path that prioritizes early work or entrepreneurial experience? The answer for your family depends on your specific goals, financial situation, and your child’s interests.

    Opportunity Cost — The Hidden Expense Even With a Full Ride

    Often, we think a full ride means “free education.” But what about the value of four years your child could spend gaining work experience, internships, or starting ventures? This opportunity cost is real.

    Think about this: if the tuition, room, and board are paid, but your daughter spends four years not working or building her entrepreneurial venture, could those years delay financial independence? And what about the risk of a long journey with a major that leads to a less employable skillset?

    Even with free tuition, ask:
    What skills and practical experience will my child gain while attending this school?
    Will this school environment encourage internships, apprenticeships, or co-op programs?
    Could she balance part-time work with studies to build real-world experience?

    Choosing a Major and Curriculum — Prioritize Practicality and Skills

    Throughout the podcast discussion, one point stood out: favor programs that teach practical, applicable skills over purely theoretical knowledge. For example:

    • Engineering programs with hands-on lab experience and research opportunities.
    • Computer science curricula emphasizing current programming tools and real applications rather than only theoretical computing science.
    • Business or psychology combined with entrepreneurship where students learn to navigate real-world problems.

    Employers value candidates who can demonstrate immediate impact. Meanwhile, your child develops skills that can adapt as technology and job markets evolve rapidly—especially in an AI-augmented world.

    The Value of School Size, Culture, and Environment

    Not every student thrives in a large institution like Cornell, where lectures can have hundreds of students and bureaucracy is significant. Smaller schools may offer more personalized guidance, easier access to professors, and more opportunities for collaborative projects.

    On the other hand, big universities have vast alumni networks, extensive resources, and diverse student bodies to build social and professional capital.

    Consider weather, location, and lifestyle too—will your child thrive in upstate New York winters or a warmer Southern campus? Will she prefer a more structured environment or an independent, sink-or-swim experience?

    Leveraging Technology and Alternative Learning

    One compelling insight from the podcast is that the marginal cost of disseminating educational content is plummeting thanks to technology. You can access top-notch lectures, course materials, and even certifications online, often free or at much lower cost.

    That means you can craft “NotCornell”—a customized path where your child learns core knowledge online, actively seeks internships, builds entrepreneurial ventures, and saves or invests the money otherwise spent on tuition or room and board.

    Financially, this can turbocharge your child’s wealth-building potential. Investing tuition savings in a solid portfolio over four years could jumpstart capital accumulation, funding future ventures, grad school, or even early retirement.

    Money Matters — Financing, Savings, and Investment Strategies

    As a fiduciary advisor, I stress the importance of viewing college through the lens of an investment decision, comparing the expected return on investment (ROI) considering all costs.

    • If your child has full rides but high room and board costs, negotiate possibilities of living at home or with less expensive housing options.
    • Encourage your child to seek internships and part-time roles. Experience blends with education to build employability.
    • Consider setting up a 529 college savings plan for any out-of-pocket expenses or future education such as graduate school.
    • If opting for a NotCornell path, make sure savings from tuition are invested prudently—diversified stocks and bonds portfolios can compound over years to grow capital.

    Example: Assuming $50,000 annual tuition and expenses saved by choosing NotCornell and invested at a 7% historical return, after four years, this could grow to over $230,000—impacting future financial freedom opportunities.

    Teach Your Child Financial Literacy and How to Learn

    A strong recurring theme was the importance of learning how to learn, lifelong learning, and developing financial literacy early on.

    Encourage your child to master these vital skills:

    • Setting and managing a budget and understanding the basics of investing
    • Building resilience through failure and networking
    • Finding mentors and consulting experts (including AI tools)
    • Learning practical skills relevant to her career interests and the future job market
    • Sharpening interpersonal and leadership skills through clubs, sports, or projects

    These human skills remain essential in an AI-driven economy and can be learned inside or outside the traditional collegiate environment.

    When Should You Say “Go to Cornell”?

    If the intangible benefits—the brand, prestige, networking, personal growth in that environment, and the specific, rigorous curriculum—align closely with your child’s ambitions and personality, and if she’s excited about the experience, then the value could outweigh even the heavy costs.

    However, even in that case, approach the decision with a clear plan to maximize practical experience alongside academic studies. This might mean:

    • Securing internships summers and during semesters
    • Engaging in on-campus incubators or entrepreneurial groups
    • Building relationships with professors and alumni
    • Living within means and maintaining financial discipline

    Summary — A Financial Advisor’s Takeaway

    College selection is a high-stakes financial decision that requires more than just value judgements about prestige. Here’s how you can guide yourself and your child:

    1. Clarify goals: What are the priorities—education quality, career preparation, social environment, work experience?
    2. Evaluate opportunity cost: Consider the value of four years spent in college vs. alternate paths like work, entrepreneurship, or part-time study.
    3. Analyze curriculum: Choose majors and programs emphasizing practical skills applicable to the future job market.
    4. Consider school size and culture: Does your child need more support and guidance, or do they thrive in less structured environments?
    5. Leverage technology: Combine traditional education with online learning to lower costs and improve outcomes.
    6. Prioritize financial literacy: Teach budgeting, investing, networking, and adaptive learning early.
    7. Invest sensibly: If saving tuition costs, invest the savings in diversified, low-cost portfolios aiming for long-term growth.
    8. Keep an open mind: The educational landscape is shifting, and flexibility is a competitive advantage.

    Ultimately, it’s about aligning finances with freedom: freedom from crippling debt, freedom to pursue meaningful work, and freedom to build a secure future. Whether that path is Cornell or NotCornell, the best financial plan accounts for all the variables and empowers your child to make educated, confident choices.

    Feel free to reach out or comment if you want help developing a personalized college funding strategy or investment management plan as you prepare your family’s financial roadmap.

    Press Play to Dive Deeper with The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast

    Need More Help?

    If you’re ever in need of guidance, these blog posts may be of help. But be sure to contact a financial, tax, or legal professional for guidance and information specific to your individual situation. And as always you can reach out to me directly here with questions or concerns about your personal situation.

    Stay Updated with Investing Forever Advisory

    * indicates required


    Disclaimer

  • The information provided in the blog post is for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be considered as financial advice or a recommendation to invest in any specific investment or investment strategy.
  • Past performance is not indicative of future results, and any investment involves risks, including the potential loss of principal.
  • The financial advisor makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, and shall not be liable for any damages arising from any reliance on or use of such information.
  • Any views or opinions expressed in the blog post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the financial advisor’s firm or its affiliates.
  • The financial advisor’s firm may have positions in some of the securities or investments discussed in the blog post, and such positions may change at any time without notice.
  • Investors should consult with a financial advisor or professional to determine their own investment objectives, risk tolerance, and other factors before making any investment decisions.
  • This post has been edited for completeness and includes material generated with the assistance of ChatGPT.
    • Posted on

    The Cost of Higher Education Is Too High. Here’s What You Can Do

    Press Play to Hear This Post

    Insights from The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast Episode #25

    Higher education remains one of the most significant investments families make, often accompanied by a mix of excitement and financial anxiety. For high-performance professionals like you, planning for college expenses can be overwhelming, especially as tuition and associated costs continue to rise well above typical inflation rates. But while the sticker shock is real, this doesn’t mean you’re powerless. With strategic, flexible financial planning, you can position yourself to fund your children’s education affordably—without sacrificing your own financial security and freedom.

    This article is inspired by a detailed conversation on the Mind Money Spectrum podcast (published on June 2, 2020), where we examined college savings through a realistic, practical lens. Below, I’ll summarize key insights and actionable steps for families preparing to face the high cost of college head-on.

    How Much Does College Really Cost?

    Understanding current costs is the foundation of your plan. For context, consider these ballpark figures (reflecting 2020 data and variable by institution and location):

    • In-state Public Universities (e.g., UCLA): ~$35,000 per year including tuition, fees, room, and board.
    • Other Public Universities (e.g., California State University campuses): ~$27,000 per year.
    • Community Colleges: Roughly $3,000 to $4,000 annually for tuition alone (room and board often not included).
    • Private Universities (e.g., Ivy League, Stanford): Approximately $70,000 to $75,000 per year.

    It’s important to remember these amounts will almost certainly increase over the next 15 to 20 years due to inflation, often outpacing the general Consumer Price Index (CPI). Historically, college costs have risen roughly 4% to 5% annually, whereas CPI tends to hover around 2% to 3%. This gap is a big reason why many parents begin saving early.

    Factor in Inflation and Investment Growth

    When projecting future costs, two critical assumptions drive your planning:

    • College Inflation Rate: The annual rate at which college costs are expected to increase. Conservative planning often assumes 5% because college inflation has historically exceeded general inflation.
    • Investment Rate of Return: The expected annual growth rate of your investments. A moderate figure would be 7% for a diversified portfolio of stocks and bonds over the long term.

    Assuming a newborn today plans to attend a public university like UCLA in about 18 years, saving roughly $700 per month or a lump sum of around $95,000 could fully cover four years of education—assuming a 5% inflation rate on costs and 7% investment return. For a private university, the savings target can easily double, often reaching $1,300 to $1,400 per month.

    529 Plans: Your Best Ally in College Savings

    The 529 college savings plan stands out as the most effective savings vehicle designed specifically for education, and here’s why:

    • Tax Advantages: Although contributions are made with after-tax dollars (with some states offering tax deductions on contributions), the growth in your 529 plan is tax-free when used for qualified education expenses, which include tuition, fees, books, supplies, and even room and board.
    • Flexible Beneficiaries: You can change the beneficiary of your 529 plan to another family member if, for example, your older child decides not to attend college or accepts scholarships. This flexibility is highly valuable when planning for multiple children.
    • Parental Control: Unlike custodial accounts, the account holder (usually a parent) maintains control of the funds—including withdrawals and investment decisions—until the money is disbursed.
    • Age-Based Investment Strategies: Most 529 plans offer age-based portfolios that automatically become more conservative as your child nears college age, protecting your savings from market volatility as the time to spend nears.
    • Higher Contribution Limits: You can contribute substantial sums, including “super-funding” by prepaying up to five years’ worth of gifts in one year (up to $75,000 per contributor in 2020), providing significant front-loading flexibility.

    Additional Considerations and Strategies

    1. Start Early but Don’t Panic if You’re Behind

    The power of compounding growth cannot be overstated. The earlier you start, the easier it is to reach your target with manageable monthly contributions. However, if you’re starting later in your child’s life, focus on consistent investing and consider a balanced but growth-oriented mix.

    2. Retirement Comes First

    Your own retirement security must always be your primary financial priority. Unlike college, there’s no scholarship or loan program to cover retirement. It’s better to pay for college with a combination of savings, scholarships, and loans than risk your future financial independence.

    3. Keep an Open Dialogue—and Be Prepared to Pivot

    Trying to predict your child’s future college choices when they are an infant is nearly impossible. Your child might choose a community college, earn scholarships, attend graduate school, or even skip college. It’s important to maintain flexibility by not overcommitting all your financial resources to college savings alone.

    4. Consider Taxable Investment Accounts for Added Flexibility

    If you anticipate the possibility of your child not needing all the funds earmarked for college, or if you want more flexibility in how money can be used, opening a taxable investment account with a long-term, diversified portfolio may be a smart complement to your 529 plan savings. This allows you easy access and use of the funds—without tax penalties—if education costs change.

    5. Use Your Earning Potential to Your Advantage

    Many high-performance professionals experience income growth throughout their careers, particularly in their 40s and 50s. If you keep lifestyle inflation in check, you might be able to cover unexpected college expenses out of current cash flow rather than relying entirely on savings.

    6. Scholarship and Financial Aid Could Help Reduce the Burden

    Research and encourage your child to pursue scholarships and grants. Some schools even have initiatives offering free tuition for families below certain income thresholds. Factoring these potential benefits into your plan can reduce the overall amount you’ll need to save.

    7. Evaluate Prepaid Tuition Plans—With Caution

    Some states offer prepaid tuition plans where you lock in today’s tuition rates for future attendance at in-state public colleges. While these can protect against tuition inflation risk, they often have restrictions on flexibility and move with you if you relocate; changes can be costly. Evaluate carefully before committing.

    Why I Don’t Recommend Alternative Investments for College Savings

    As a fiduciary, my role is to recommend investments aligned with your goals, risk tolerance, and timelines. For college savings, I favor stocks and bonds within tax-advantaged accounts like 529 plans because of their proven growth, liquidity, and regulation transparency. Alternative investments often come with higher complexity, fees, and illiquidity, making them less suitable for a goal with a defined timeline and spending requirement like college funding.

    Key Takeaway: Balance, Flexibility, and Perspective

    The cost of higher education is daunting and likely to rise faster than inflation, but with prudent planning and disciplined saving strategies, funding your child’s college education is achievable without jeopardizing your own financial future.

    Some final points to remember:

    • Start with realistic cost projections. Use conservative assumptions, but revisit them periodically to adjust your savings plan.
    • Utilize 529 plans for tax-efficient growth and control.
    • Make your retirement plans a priority. There will be other ways to fund college besides risking your financial independence.
    • Maintain communication and flexibility. Your child’s path may change, so your plan should be able to adapt.
    • Leverage scholarships, grants, and financial aid. They are powerful tools that can ease your saving requirements.

    Ultimately, saving for college is a marathon, not a sprint. Thoughtful planning today—combined with disciplined investing and a balanced approach—will give you the financial freedom you seek for you and your family.

    If you’d like to discuss how to build a smart, flexible college savings plan customized for your family’s unique situation, feel free to reach out for a fiduciary consultation tailored to your goals.

    Press Play to Dive Deeper with The Mind Money Spectrum Podcast

    Need More Help?

    If you’re ever in need of guidance, these blog posts may be of help. But be sure to contact a financial, tax, or legal professional for guidance and information specific to your individual situation. And as always you can reach out to me directly here with questions or concerns about your personal situation.

    Stay Updated with Investing Forever Advisory

    * indicates required


    Disclaimer

  • The information provided in the blog post is for educational and informational purposes only, and should not be considered as financial advice or a recommendation to invest in any specific investment or investment strategy.
  • Past performance is not indicative of future results, and any investment involves risks, including the potential loss of principal.
  • The financial advisor makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided, and shall not be liable for any damages arising from any reliance on or use of such information.
  • Any views or opinions expressed in the blog post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of the financial advisor’s firm or its affiliates.
  • The financial advisor’s firm may have positions in some of the securities or investments discussed in the blog post, and such positions may change at any time without notice.
  • Investors should consult with a financial advisor or professional to determine their own investment objectives, risk tolerance, and other factors before making any investment decisions.
  • This post has been edited for completeness and includes material generated with the assistance of ChatGPT.